NETHATE Workshop – “Contemporary issues on hate”

NETHATE organized a four-day interdisciplinary workshop – “contemporary issues on hate” in Berlin, Germany, Sep 12th-16th. Participants include members of NETHATE Marie Skłodowska-Curie ITN project, and NGO staff members. Prof. Zoë James from the University of Plymouth and Dr. Daniel Geschke from Institut für Demokratie und Zivilgesellschaft chaired the workshop.

The workshop has two main parts. The first part focuses on Right-wing extremism in Germany: historical development & recent developments such as online RWE media & propaganda strategies and innovative forms of right-wing extremism. The second part focuses on theoretical approaches to researching hate speech and crime. As two of the main objectives, this workshop can complement the presentation and discussion of critical approaches to hate speech online and offline. This workshop can also facilitate the communication between early-stage researchers in the NETHATE project with practitioners in NGOs, and activists, to better understand and use their knowledge to contribute to solving the real-life problem.

Guest speakers in this workshop include Barbara Perry from the Ontario Tech University; Kamran Khan from the University of Copenhagen; Jennifer Kamau from the International Women* Space, Berlin; Miriam Juan Torres from the Othering & Belonging Institute at UC Berkeley; Simone Rafael from the Amadeu Antonio Stiftung; Zoë James, Katie McBride, Chris Pac-Soo from the University of Plymouth; Axel Salheiser, Christoph Richter, Viktoria Kamuf & Maik from the Fielitz Institut für Demokratie und Zivilgesellschaft.

During the workshop, participants engaged with experts, academics, practitioners, activists, and our early-stage researchers in NETHATE on contemporary issues on hate, including far-right, racism, critical perspectives on hate, and more!

Open speech of the four-day workshop given by Daniel Geschke from Institut für Demokratie und Zivilgesellschaft

To make sure everyone can share their knowledge, experiences, opinions, and feelings in a safe and non-judgment environment; to make sure the workshop can, in the end, brings out constructive advice for all participants; to make sure everyone can learn and freely exchange ideas; to make sure people from different fields and backgrounds can understand each other; at the very beginning of the four-day workshop, participants together discussed and defined a set of standard rules for how to communicate with each other.

Discussion for a set of standard communication rules

Workshop Agenda

WHENWHOWHATINTERACTION
DAY1
09:30- 10:30Daniel Geschke (IDCS Jena)An overall introduction of seminar contentWhat do you want to get out of it? What are you interested in? How does it relate to your research project?
11:00- 12:30Axel Salheiser (IDCS Jena)Overview of the development of the far right in Germany
13:30- 15:00Viktoria Kamuf (IDCS Jena)Othered places: On the relationship between racism and space in the case of the 2020 far-right attack in Hanau, Germany
15:30- 17:00
Dr Kamran Khan
(University of Copenhagen)
Raciolinguistic perspectives on ‘raceless’ societies
DAY2
09:00- 10:30Maik Fielitz (IDCS Jena)Right-Wing Extremism Online: Media and propaganda strategies of the far right in Germany
11:00- 13:00Christoph Richter (IDCS Jena)The far right in the German parliament: reasons for the current successes of the AfD (“Alternative für Deutschland” “alternative for Germany”)
14:00- 15:00Miriam Juan Torres (Belonging Institute)
15:00- 16:00Daniel Geschke (IDCS Jena)Interactive integration and summary of days 1 and 2
DAY3
09:00- 10:30Zoë James, Katie McBride (University of Plymouth)Lecture: Introduction to critical theorizing
An introductory lecture presenting critical social science theories that have
been used to explain hateful behaviors in the 21st century
This session functions as a traditional lecture that will set out core areas of critical theorizing: identifying foundational knowledge on how power functions in social life that impacts and informs hate offending and victimization via systems and structures of governance and global social, political, and economic norms. The session will focus on aspects of bias-motivated behaviors that are acknowledged within the hate studies canon, specifically race, sexuality, class, gender identity, religion or belief, disability, and gender, however, it will incorporate consideration of the boundaries of hate victimization and intersectionality.
11:00- 12:30Chris Pac-Soo (University of Plymouth)Seminar: Critical Perspectives on Race and Racism
Seminar with guest speaker for approximately 45 minutes, followed by 45 minutes discussion. Students will consider the speaker presentation and the reading they have completed during discussion that will inform their work in Day 2 of the workshop.
Dr. Chris Pac-Soo is an expert in teaching and researching critical race perspectives.
This session focuses on critical perspectives on race and racism. The session considers how race hate has manifested, been explained, and challenged as part of critical theory discourse. The session engages with foundational issues of how race, socialization, and racism are understood and inform everyday experiences. The session acknowledges the need for decolonial criticality that engages with Critical Race Theory and intersectionality as mechanisms to challenge white privilege.
13:30- 15:00Barbara Perry (Ontario Tech University)Professor Perry is a guest speaker at this workshop. As the leading critical scholar in hate studies, who also sits on the External Advisory Board of NETHATE, Professor Perry provides an informative talk on the parameters of hate theorization and, in doing so, makes direct connections to the training on the far right.
15:30-17:00Jennifer Kamau
(International Women* Space, Berlin)
Activism and Documentation as Tools of ResistanceFilm Showing as part of the session: “Kampfer*innen” to inform discussion on Visibility and Resistance.
DAY4
Full-dayKatie McBride, Zoë James (University of Plymouth)Students use this session to consider how their research interests may be impacted by critical theories in studying hate. This session will act as a collaborative space wherein some time will be given to individual contemplation. Still, all ESRs are grouped in free will to maximize shared learning and understanding of critical concepts. Engaging in a reflective, open, and collegiate manner is the key to the session’s success. ESRs are supported in the session by a guided training plan to orient their thinking and collaborative approach to consider their projects.

On the first day, we started the workshop with @dauerstoerung presenting on #RightWing#Extremism in #Germany @IDZ_Jena

Next, we heard from @vikikamuf about the 2020 #FarRight #Attack in #Hanau#Germany on the relationship between #racism and #space@IDZ_Jena

Ending a great first day of the workshop, @SecurityLing discussed #Raciolinguistic perspectives on ‘#raceless’ societies @MSCActions

On day two, we started to explore the #hate on social media and other online environments with @maik_fielitz presenting “#RightWing#Extremism#Online: #Media and #propaganda strategies of the far right in #Germany

Online, we heard @miriamjtg about her work at the @oandbinstitute

At the end of day two, we heard @drachenschafe discussing her work at @AmadeuAntonio with a particular focus on “#Fighting the #farright, #antisemitism and #racism #offline and #online”.

On the third day, we started the second part of our ‘Workshop on Contemporary issues on hate’ with a specific focus on “#CriticalStudies on #Hate”. In the morning, @DrZoeJames taught the “Introduction to #CriticalTheorising”. Continuing with @DrChrisPacsoo presenting on “#CriticalPerspectives on #Race and #Racism”, followed by Dr. Barbara Perry talking on “The Continuum of #Hate@CHBEOntarioTech

An incredibly impressive and touching moment was at the end of the third day when we heard from Jennifer Kamau from @iwspace about the stories of victims/survivors. The @iwspace (https://iwspace.de/)is a #feminist, #antiracist political group in #Berlin of migrant, refugee, and non-refugee women. They fight patriarchy and document violence, racism, sexism, and other discrimination in movies and books (which may be continuous erasure, and lack of representation, within mainstream media). From the documentaries, we witnessed the real-life stories and life experiences of migrant women. The intense emotions and resilience of the survivors touched everyone in the room.

You can buy their books on their website. Their books document the experiences of + create an archive for, migrant + refugee women in Germany

Please follow our Twitter account (@NETHATE_ITN), Linkedin account (https://www.linkedin.com/company/marie-sk%C5%82odowska-curie-itn-nethate/), and YouTube channels (https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCNea025Jg-Q-6AyKk3Wf1Cg) if you are interested in the following workshops.